you're reading...
"New to me" reviews

Ever In My Heart (1933)

project2

Mary Archer (Barbara Stanwyck), a beautiful and young American girl, is patiently awaiting the return of her friend(/sometimes boyfriend) Jeff (Ralph Bellamy) from active duty in Germany.

When Jeff finally does return, he brings back a German friend named Hugo (Otto Kruger). Rather than taking up a romance with Jeff as she had expected, Mary falls for Hugo. (I would have marked that as a minor spoiler, but did anyone really think Bellamy was going to get the girl in this one?)

The two eventually marry and live a quite prosperous life. Hugo works at a college, and their marriage is a happy one.

But when World War I reaches its end and anti-German sentiment begins to penetrate America, troubles arise for the couple, including pressure from Mary’s family for Hugo to denounce his heritage.

Archie Mayo directs the 1933 drama Ever in My Heart. The film was written by Beulah Marie Dix and Bertram Millhauser.

I watched this film back-to-back with The Secret Bride, which you may remember from the last Barbara Stanwyck filmography update I wasn’t a huge fan of. In comparison, this one has so much  more energy from the start that it was bound to win me over at least partially.

Once again, Stanwyck gives a great performance in this film. She’s very endearing and likable. Her performance, in combination with that of Kruger and the chemistry between them, ensures that the viewer will care about the film’s characters and plot.

(Image: Film Affinity)

(Image: Film Affinity)

Ever in My Heart is a bit of a mixed bag in terms of themes and significance. It deals with political drama, anti-immigrant/anti-German sentiment, the very strained relations between Americans and “foreigners,” the pressures of family and society to conform. The effect that prejudice has on what was a lovely marriage between Mary and Hugo provokes thought from the viewer that is still relevant in today’s world.

The highly emotional performances of both Stanwyck and Kruger really carry the film and make the viewer become invested in the story, but there is solid support here as well. These supporting performances are believable, but never overpower the leads. They stay in the background and out of the film’s true spotlight while also provoking feeling from the viewer, and especially the viewer who sympathizes with Stanwyck and Kruger’s characters.

An unexpected ending keeps up the somber mood of the film. Ever in My Heart fits perfectly on the list of Stanwyck’s great dramatic roles. The score: 4/5

About Lindsey

Lindsey loves film, photography, camping, Cary Grant and dogs.

Discussion

7 thoughts on “Ever In My Heart (1933)

  1. Well, look at you with your new font style and new sidebar thing! Very cool!

    And you asked how anyone would think Ralph Bellamy would get the girl in this one? How the heck did OTTO KRUGER get the girl? Has he ever played anything but a pleasant-but-cruel German villain? What’s going on here?

    And wait, let me guess: the surprise ending involves Kruger tying up Bellamy in a basement in New York City and…wait, that might’ve been Saboteur. Or maybe it was Sex and the Single Girl…

    Posted by Todd Benefiel | February 1, 2013, 3:20 am
    • A brick wall could get the girl before Bellamy, though! Kruger may have played evil a lot but he plays nice here and plays it well :P You could be right, though – maybe there’s a sequel I don’t know about where he turns smarmy and kidnaps Bellamy.

      As for the new sidebar, I’ve had those images in the projects and category tabs at the top of the site but those pages don’t get a ton of views, so I wanted the links to be more accessible. Glad you like them! Top film of the week and all that jazz can still be found on the homepage.

      Posted by Lindsey | February 1, 2013, 10:57 am
      • Y’know, I think you’re right about that brick wall idea…I seem to remember he lost out on female companionship in His Girl Friday as well. And I’m sure he must’ve lost out in Amazon Women On The Moon, too!

        Yes, I like the new sidebar…I’ll be sure to use it!

        Posted by Todd Benefiel | February 1, 2013, 11:47 am
        • I think I’ve only ever seen one film where he manages to successfully woo the lady (and I’m completely blanking on the name of it, haha).

          Posted by Lindsey | February 1, 2013, 11:51 am
  2. This sounds like a thought-provoking movie.

    And poor Ralph Bellamy! I have to start looking for movies where he did end up with the girl!

    Posted by silverscreenings | February 1, 2013, 8:32 pm
    • Anne Baxter falls in love with him in ‘Guest in the House,’ which I reviewed for the Mill Creek Musings series… but he’s already married and she’s a completely crazy stalker, so I don’t think that one counts in his favor haha. You’ll have to let me know if you find any where he gets the girl without such complications!

      Posted by Lindsey | February 1, 2013, 11:34 pm

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: What to Watch #19: June 12 – 18 | the motion pictures - June 11, 2013

Enter your email to follow TMP and get brand spankin' new, Cary Grant approved classic film content sent directly to your inbox!
(*Cary Grant does not actually endorse this blog, but I'd like to think he does.)

Join 3,183 other followers

TMP Archives:

Today’s popular posts:

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,183 other followers

%d bloggers like this: