The Great Man’s Lady (1942)

This film was viewed for the Barbara Stanwyck Filmography Project. To see more reviews from this project, visit my Listography page!

This film was viewed for the Barbara Stanwyck Filmography Project, wherein I am attempting to watch and review every one of Stanwyck’s films. To see more reviews from this project, visit my Listography page!

As the saying goes, “Behind every great man stands a greater woman.” According to The Great Man’s Lady, behind every great man stands a Hannah Hoyt. She’s the quintessential “greater woman.”

The film’s opening titles read: “Meeting Hannah Hoyt, the great man’s lady, would not be so important if there were only one Hannah Hoyt; but, fortunately, the miracle of a Hannah Hoyt happens again and again, from generation to generation of American womanhood. Not only behind great men, but behind the ordinary guy — you will see a Hannah Hoyt. In her own small way, she will be helping, pointing the road ahead, encouraging her man to reach his own pinnacle of success.”

(Image via Movie Poster Shop)

(Image via Movie Poster Shop)

We’ve seen countless stories about the great men, but William Wellman’s 1942 film aims to finally tell the other side of the story. At 100 years of age, Hannah is interviewed by a young biographer and reflects on her life as the wife of legendary pioneer Ethan Hoyt. The Great Man’s Lady was written for the screen by W. L. River, from an original story by Adela Rogers St. Johns and Seena Owen, and a short story by Vina Delmar.

This film appears in The Barbara Stanwyck Collection from the Universal Backlot Series. The DVD set includes a few facts about each film; it is noted that to prepare for her scenes as an elderly woman, Stanwyck visited retirement homes and observed the behavior/mannerisms of elderly women.

Stanwyck doesn’t spend the entire film in age-transforming makeup, but her research for that part of the character was successful, contributing to yet another fantastic Stanwyck performance. The makeup used to transform her into an elderly woman is pretty well-done, and she’s very convincing throughout the decades of her character’s life. As an older Hannah, her voice is quieter than usual and slightly raspy, her movements slow and stiff. As young Hannah in the earliest stages of her romance with Ethan, she’s bright-eyed and excitable.

(Image via Movie Poster Shop)

(Image via Movie Poster Shop)

The character of Hannah is a great one. She’s incredibly strong, with a great sense of determination to make the dream of “Hoyt City” come true and the ability to adapt to any change that comes her way.

As for the film on the whole, it has a few issues that will stick out to the modern viewer. In her youth, Stanwyck’s character is cared for by an outspoken “mammy” — a role not much different than that played by Hattie McDaniel in Gone With the Wind. There’s also quite a bit of talk about the “evil” tribes that will be faced by pioneers as the country expands Westward.

Despite these unnecessary stereotypes, the film is for the most part a wonderful watch. The chemistry between Stanwyck and her leading man, Joel McCrea, is great. They’re adorable and fun to watch together during the happiest times of their lives, and heartbreaking to watch when problems turn their lives upside down. The affection and genuine caring between their characters is so obvious that the couple is very easy to root for, even when the complications of life threaten to tear them apart for good.

A fine (and emotionally-effective) script, a bittersweet romance, and nice cinematography add to the appeal of The Great Man’s Lady, but the film’s strongest asset is “the great man’s lady” herself: Barbara Stanwyck in the strongly-performed and well-crafted character of Hannah Hoyt. The score: 4/5

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The Great Man’s Lady (1942)

  1. Lisa Alkana says:

    I love the movie, but find it difficult to watch, as parts of it are so utterly heartbreaking. I feel I have to mention that the perceived gaps in the story work because it is a tale told by a very elderly woman. My only issue with movie is that we never really see what’s so great about the man — other than looking look like Joel McCrea.

    Like

    • Lindsey says:

      It is definitely an emotional watch. Happy to hear that you love it, even if it breaks your heart!

      Personally, I did not have the same issue as you — I’m glad that not a whole lot of focus was put on McCrea’s character. He’s a “great man” in the sense that he left a legacy. A town is named after him, and he’s well-known enough for someone to write a biography about him. His name will probably appear in history books, in the film’s world. But this is Hannah’s story, not his, and the film makes that clear by keeping the focus on Stanwyck and letting her character’s complexities shine through. She could be the wife of any “great man” — one of the founding fathers, a famed activist, a powerful businessman, etc. Her husband’s identity matters less than her own personality and journey, and I really appreciated that about this film.

      Like

Comments are closed.