A note from Lindsey: Welcome to Day 2 of the Gish Sisters Blogathon! Today I’m posting a Lillian review, and tomorrow will be dedicated to Dorothy, but I’ll also be keeping up with the master list of everyone’s contributions as the celebration continues. To see what all of our wonderful participants have come up with, visit yesterday’s post, “The Gish Sisters Blogathon is here!”
Lillian Gish led an incredibly long career, spanning nearly eight decades and including 120 film and television credits. She made her film debut in 1912, and her final film was released in 1987… a whole 75 years later!
Lillian and her sister are both best-remembered for their work in silent film, but as with any actor from the silent or classic eras of Hollywood, the films that the Gish sisters made later in their careers can be just as fascinating, valuable and entertaining as the films that made them legends.
Lillian’s penultimate film, Sweet Liberty, is one that deserves a look.
Released in 1986, the film stars Alan Alda (who also wrote and directed it), Michael Caine and Michelle Pfeiffer. The story follows history teacher Michael Burgess (Alda), a man who has sold the film rights to a book he wrote about the revolutionary war.
Michael finds that adapting his book for the screen will not be as easy as he thought it would be, when a film crew shows up and it becomes clear that they want to change everything about his source material — the characters, the battles, all of it. Having written a scholarly and informative piece of research, these changes are not exactly welcomed by the author.
Meanwhile, Michael must also contend with his not-quite-all-there mother, his wedding-obsessed girlfriend, and his growing infatuation with Faith (Pfeiffer), the actress set to play the female lead in the adaptation of his book.
Lillian Gish’s role is that of Cecelia Burgess, Michael’s mother.
Age has always been a strange factor in Hollywood movie-making. Some performers, such as Meryl Streep, completely defy Hollywood’s habit of giving greater roles to younger actors who are seen as being “in their prime” (read as: young). Some actors, on the other hand, get relegated to bland, insignificant supporting roles as they age.
When I began watching Sweet Liberty, I fully expected Lillian’s role to be one of that bland, supporting type. On paper, she sounds like the stereotypical “mother losing her marbles” — a small addition to the film that doesn’t add much except for a couple of laughs. After all, the film’s focus is not Michael’s relationship with his family, but his grand Hollywood encounter.
Sweet Liberty luckily exceeded my expectations both as a whole and in terms of Lillian’s role.
The film is a very fun watch, though not a “laugh every minute” comedy. It offers romance, humor, a bit of drama and a satirical look at the Hollywood filmmaking process (particularly for costume dramas/historical “bodice-rippers”). The performances are solid and Alda’s flair for writing shines, particularly through his script’s dialogue, which flows seamlessly.
Lillian’s screen time is quite small, as expected, but she does much more than add a few small laughs to the movie. That’s not to say she isn’t hilarious — she is! The character is written very well. She makes her son have full-blown conversations with her dog, is obsessed with an ex-boyfriend she hasn’t seen in half a century, makes jokes about poisoned food, has so many locks on her door that she can barely unlock them and believes that the Devil himself lives in her kitchen.
Beyond sheer comedic value, the interactions between Michael and his mother, however brief, have an interesting dynamic that allows the viewer to more fully understand Michael’s personality. Even when she winds up in the hospital, Michael has a low tolerance for his mom’s nuttiness — she’s sure that the doctors are going to remove all of her nerves! He seems fed up with her most of the time, but his frustration isn’t completely unwarranted. He’s obviously very logically-minded, while she has a flair for the dramatic and kooky; their personalities clash. His intolerance of the flip-flopping and fact-ignoring ways of the Hollywood team make a lot of sense after seeing how he acts around his mother. Knowledge and accuracy are key to him, and anyone who disregards those things is perceived to be below him.
Lillian’s delivery of the character is spot-on. Not once do we see her as Lillian Gish, Classic Film Legend. The audience is easily able to believe her as Cecilia Burgess, a quirky, aging mother with an offbeat sense of humor and more than a few delusions. Lillian brings the character to life in such a way that she seems to fully buy into her character’s delusions, delivering her kooky quips without a hint of a smirk, which makes them seem all the more real (and makes them even funnier).
Lillian apparently enjoyed the experience of making this film, which was her 104th big screen role:
“Making Sweet Liberty reminded me of D.W. Griffith in 1912. There was no place we could go that was as happy as when we were shooting, and this film was just like that.”
Writer/director/star Alan Alda also relished in the experience of working with Gish:
“The one striking moment I remember in shooting Sweet Liberty was shooting a scene in a hospital bed and while they were touching up the lighting, she started to reminisce about D.W. Griffith. Everyone on the set (carpenters, grips, everyone) stopped in their tracks and listened. We all knew we were in the presence of a living history of our profession. I’ve always regretted that I was so taken with the moment that it didn’t occur to me to tell the operator to roll film on the moment.”
If only he had been able to capture that moment! Filming seems to have been a nice experience for all, and Sweet Liberty is an incredibly enjoyable watch, either for fans of Gish hoping to complete her extensive filmography or fans of comedy in general. Lillian is a definite scene stealer, and it’s wonderful to see her talent still shining brightly on display, even 74 years after her film debut.
*The quotes used above were sourced from Stuart Oderman’s “Lillian Gish: A Life on Stage and Screen.
Thanks for the review and the wonderful observations about Lillian’s performance. You picked up a lot of things that I missed when I saw the film (rewatch time?). I wish Alda had rolled the film too!
Working on my posts for this blogathon was a very interesting experience because I don’t usually pay extremely close attention to any single performance of a film. I notice strengths and weaknesses in performances, of course, but it’s easy to miss out on a lot of nuanced details when watching a film for a standard review, so watching Sweet Liberty and The Cardinal with a somewhat tunnel-visioned focus on the work of the Gish Sisters was enlightening! I was somewhat worried that, since their roles are small, there wouldn’t be much for me to build a post off of… but boy, was I wrong. I would love to hear your thoughts on the film and on Lillian’s performance when you get around to watching it again. :)
“His intolerance of the flip-flopping and fact-ignoring ways of the Hollywood team make a lot of sense after seeing how he acts around his mother.” That is an excellent observation. I didn’t make that connection when I saw the movie. Thank you for warming my heart today with this review.
Glad you enjoyed it! :)
I enjoyed reading this article a lot! I have never heard of this film but I hope to watch it in the future. The deciding factor for me was when I read, “Lillian’s delivery of the character is spot-on. Not once do we see her as Lillian Gish, Classic Film Legend. The audience is easily able to believe her as Cecilia Burgess, a quirky, aging mother with an offbeat sense of humor and more than a few delusions.”
Often times, I find myself associating Gish with that title and her role in silent pictures, but it would be nice to forget about that extratextual context and just enjoy the movie and her acting for what it is in the picture :)
If you have Netflix Instant, it’s available there. :) Hope you enjoy it as much as I did!
With stars as legendary as Lillian, it can be very difficult to separate their characters from their off-screen personas. I have this problem with Cary Grant sometimes — as much as I adore him and as much talent as he had, I often think of him as “beautiful Cary Grant playing (character name)” rather than thinking of the character as a separate entity.
I enjoyed reading this write-up very much, though I have to admit I’m not a fan of the film. I like Alan Alda a lot as an actor, but find him to be somewhat facile as a writer/director, and he shows it here; though it’s a good premise, and he has a good cast (I particularly liked Gish, as well as Michael Caine), the movie didn’t really go beyond the surface for me. Still, as I said, I enjoyed the write-up, and I especially enjoy the anecdotes you include about Alda’s view of Gish and vice versa.
I actually haven’t seen much of Alda’s work. From his filmography as writer/director I’d only seen Betsy’s Wedding, which I didn’t love. I’d forgotten that he made that one though, so I went into Sweet Liberty with non-existent expectations. I can definitely see why you’d describe it as facile but I still enjoyed watching it a lot, and that damn dialogue won me over. I’m a sucker for it!
Glad you enjoyed my post, even if we must agree to disagree. :)
Very nice review of this comedy, and I don’ t think Lillian gets much credit for comedy, even though she was quite good at it when she was given the chance. I especially like her wide range she displays in True Heart Susie where she gets quite a few laughs from me.
I need to give True Heart Susie a watch soon. :) She really excelled in both comedy and drama. Such a talented lady. Glad you enjoyed my post!
Reblogged this on TheFilmWriter.
This sounds like a great film I have to see. Yet, Lillian’s appearance is not so great, butI trust her cinematic potencial.
Thanks fo hosting this wonderful event, Lindsey!
Lillian Gish sounds like a hoot in this movie. I’ve never heard of it before, but I’m going to watch for it now.
It’s too bad that Alda didn’t have the camera rolling, like he said, when Lillian was waxing nostalgic for D.W. Griffith. However, his comments are gracious and are, in themselves, are lovely tribute to Lillian.